UT student cleared of fraud: sharing answers not considered cheating

| Rense Kuipers

A UT Health Sciences bachelor’s student has been cleared of fraud by the Examination Appeals Board (CBE) this week. The student had shared her completed assignment with fellow students.

Archive U-Today, for illustration purposes only.

The dispute between the student and the examination board dates back to the end of the previous academic year. Four days before the submission deadline, the student sent her own work to several fellow students.

The examination board argued that, by doing so, she had enabled others to commit plagiarism. In its view, this amounted to cheating by ‘allowing others to copy during assessments’, and therefore constituted fraud. As a result, the board intended to issue the student with a formal warning.

Student challenges decision

The student disagreed with the warning, which would have resulted in a note being added to her academic record. She maintained that her intention was simply to help fellow students and that she had explicitly stated they were not supposed to copy her work verbatim. She appealed the decision over the summer.

The case eventually came before the university-wide Examination Appeals Board in mid-September. The board ruled in the student’s favour, concluding that the examination board had ‘insufficiently demonstrated’ that she had made her work available to others ‘knowingly and deliberately’ for the purpose of plagiarism.

Earlier case from 2018

A key element in the UT ruling is an earlier decision by the national CBHO, the predecessor of the Council of State’s higher education appeals system, from 2018. That case concerned a student at The Hague University of Applied Sciences, and the resulting case law now applies to the UT case as well.

The ruling states: ‘It is understandable that the university of applied sciences wishes to do everything possible to prevent plagiarism, including discouraging students from sharing their work with one another. However, merely making one’s own work available to another person is far removed from what is generally understood as fraud in everyday language.’

The Examination Appeals Board therefore annulled the original decision on Monday. The student will be reimbursed for her legal costs, and the examination board has four weeks to reach a new decision.

Stay tuned

Sign up for our weekly newsletter.